Klara and the Sun Book Review
Klara is a Girl AF, an “Artificial Friend” created to be a companion for upper-class “lifted” children. Hers is a world in which, it seems, social interaction with other kids comes mainly in the form of scheduled “interactions” with “peer-group” members. Adults are carving out different lives for themselves after being displaced at their jobs by AI. There’s a sense, in the background of the story, of future violent conflict.
Fortunately, that aspect of Klara’s society remains as just that — a distant background — so we can focus on Klara’s unique viewpoint.
Solar-powered Klara spends her days in a shop with other Girl AFs and Boy AFs. Manager–we never know her real name– rotates her merchandise around the store in various positions, with the sunny spot in the window being a favorite. Until one day Josie, a girl with a mysterious illness, and her mother buy Klara. From their first meeting, you get the sense that “the Mother”–who we later learn does have an actual name–has very mixed feelings about this new addition to the family. As the story proceeds, our sense of uneasiness in this relationship and where it might be going grows as the Mother alternately makes strange requests of Klara at times and ignores her at others.
Ishiguro is excellent at the old rule of writing: “show, don’t tell.” He immerses you in Klara’s dystopian world through her unique perspective, gradually revealing more but not needing to explain or show everything.
In its 303 pages (in the hardcover edition), Klara’s journey asks us to ponder questions about the nature of the self, how we define sentience and society’s throwaway attitudes. What makes us “us?” Do we have “something unreachable inside each of us”? How do we treat things–or people–once loved that no longer serve our needs?
Is Klara sentient? As we follow Klara’s thoughts and feelings, it becomes harder for the reader to argue that she’s not. While one could conjecture that her feelings of concern for Josie result from her programming, many of her reactions appear spontaneous and genuine. Her sadness at a beggar she thinks is dead or her feelings of happiness about a chance reunion on the street appear natural–even if Klara, herself, isn’t. In fact, at times, Klara seems more concerned about others than some of the book’s humans.
And Klara seems self-aware. But she does seem to be missing at least one very human thing: self-concern. Klara will go out of her way to do something she believes will help Josie. However, she seems inhumanly unconcerned with things affecting her own being. Situations that humans would find extremely distressing, or worse.
As a solar-powered being, Klara’s ideas about and feelings toward the Sun cross over into the territory of religious belief. While charming, this was one part of the book where I had some difficulty suspending disbelief. It seems to me that an AI — one who some characters assume could be a tutor — might be programmed some knowledge of the cosmos. Enough understanding, at least, to know that the Sun doesn’t go to bed behind a barn on a nightly basis. Still, it’s an interesting exercise to speculate how, if a solar-powered AI created religion, it might look.
Kazuo Ishiguro, as usual, writes brilliantly, and this was an enjoyable read. I read it in a few sittings, and it kept calling me back to read more. However, I gave it 4.5 stars as I don’t think that it’s something that’s going to ask me to keep returning to it once read, as I did with The Remains of the Day.
Klara and the Sun Book Review
What did you think of Klara and the Sun? I’m interested in hearing what you thought! Leave a comment or add to the forum topic.
We are sorry that you found this post to be like a weak cup of decaf.
Let us improve this post!
Tell us how we can improve this post?
OK, we can't send you caffeine--or even coffee-- but we can send you new content. Subscribe to our email list and get new posts delivered to your inbox. If you don't specify preferences, you'll be signed up for a weekly digest of new posts in all categories, as well as occasional promotional emails and surveys. However, if you would like to customize the frequency and type of content you receive, you can sign up here.